Rich, savory, and straight from the sea, this dish is where coastal flavor meets comfort food. These Shrimp & Crab-Stuffed Portabella Mushrooms are packed with tender seafood, creamy cheese, and a touch of spice, creating a bite that’s both elegant and hearty. Whether you’re hosting guests or just treating yourself to something special, this recipe brings a restaurant-worthy experience right to your own kitchen, Fire & Salt Co style.

Prep time: 30 minutes                                                         

Cook time: 20 minutes

Ingredients:

·       3 Large whole portabella Mushrooms

  •        16 ounces Wulf’s Large Shrimp (tails removed)
  •           4 ounces Imitation crab meat
  •             4 ounces cream cheese softened
  •             1 tablespoon Olivelle Garlic & Herb Olive Oil
  •             1 tablespoon Olivelle Maple Smoked Bacon Olive Oil
  •             2 tablespoon Olivelle Sicilian Lemon olive oil
  •             4 ounces Meister white cheddar cheese (shredded)
  •            6 ounces Carr Valley Parmesan cheese (shredded)
  •           1 Tablespoon Mike’s Own seasoning
  •           1 Tablespoon of Heath Riles Simple Citrus
  •           1/2  tablespoon Heath Riles Garlic Butter Rib

 

Instructions:

Pre-heat Big Green Egg to 350 degrees direct heat

·       Mix Garlic Herb Olive oil, Mike’s own and Simple citrus. For marinade

·       Place shrimp in marinade for 30 minutes

·       Place shrimp on skewers, grill for 5 minutes until opaque turning once

·       Remove and allow it to cool slightly, set 12 pieces of shrimp aside to be used later

·       Dice the remaining shrimp and crab meat into small pieces

·       Rinse and clean mushrooms, removing stems and gills

·       Dice stems and gills into small pieces.

·       Combine Cream Cheese, mushroom pieces, shrimp, crab meat, cheddar cheese  

·       Brush underside of mushrooms with Olivelle Smoked Maple Bacon Oil

·       Stuff mushrooms with mixture

·       Place shredded Parmesan cheese on top of mixture

·       Sprinkle lightly with Mike’s Own seasoning.

·       Place 4 whole cooked shrimp on each mushroom.

Place on smoker or grill for 15 minutes or until cheese is melted and internal temp of 140 degrees.

October 08, 2025 — Kristen Smith

Leave a comment