BeefOlive Oil & Balsamic VinegarSpecials and Subscription BoxesSeafoodSeasoningSnacks and DipsGift BundlesGift Cards and CertificatesShirts and TumblersHumidorsKitchen Tools

Cheese

Carr Valley Smoked Pepper Jack

A Monterey Jack cheese with green and red jalapeno peppers that has a mild smoky flavor, giving it a wonderfully added punch! Melts well and easy to use in many recipes.
$7.95 USD Sold Out
Buy Now

Carr Valley Parmesan Cheese

$6.95 USD
Buy Now

Meister Wild Morel & Leek Jack

Our semi-soft Monterey Jack is blended with wild, earthy morel mushrooms and delicately flavored leeks. This creamy, uniquely flavored cheese is a real crowd pleaser, pairs well with light wines and is the original Morel & Leek Jack ever produced!
$7.49 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Gouda Cheese Spread

Our smooth and creamy Gouda spread is made with real Wisconsin Gouda and is perfect on crackers, crudites or added to any dish for an extra cheesy flavor!
$7.95 USD
Buy Now
5 in stock

Carr Valley Bacon Bread Cheese

We are excited to add a new flavor to our line of Bread Cheese–Bacon! We use all-natural, hickory smoked bacon throughout our classic Bread Cheese. Heat up and enjoy as a snack or pair with fruit chutney for a sweet and savory appetizer.
$7.95 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Menage Cheese

This mixed-milk beauty is aged for intense flavor and a drier texture. It’s dipped in a lovely wax as vibrant and green as Wisconsin’s summertime pastures.
$8.95 USD
Buy Now

Meister Garlic Pesto Jack

This semi-soft cheese with the perfect balance of garlic and basil is great on your favorite cracker or topping a pizza.
$7.49 USD
Buy Now

Meister Colby Jack 8oz

The mild flavors of Colby and Monterey Jack mingle in this mellow, pleasant tasting and versatile cheese. The perfect blend.
$6.95 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Marisa

A seasonal cheese made with milk from pastured Wisconsin sheep. It is white in color and its flavor is mellow, complex and sweet–qualities that reminded Sid of his daughter, Marisa for whom he named the cheese. This is a great sheep milk cheese to try if you are new to the “sheep cheese world”!.
$6.95 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Gruyere

A cheese originally made in Switzerland made and aged here in Wisconsin in copper vats. This cheese is aged for more than a year and has a sweet flavor traditionally used for cooking, fondue component and a great eating cheese.
$6.95 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Glacier Point Blue Cheese Crumbles

$5.95 USD
Buy Now

Carr Valley Chocolate Cheese

Chocolate and cheese? Yes, please. This Wisconsin favorite is rich and creamy. The perfect treat! CONTAINS NUTS.
$8.95 USD Sold Out
Buy Now

Carr Valley Apple Smoked Garlic Cheddar

With flavor that’s so bold, deep and delicious, Sid says this cheese should be placed on the “Controlled Substance” list. One try, and we think you will agree!
$6.95 USD
Buy Now
3 in stock

Carr Valley Aged Swiss Cheese

Hand selected, this Swiss Cheese is aged 2 years or more.
$7.95 USD
Buy Now